Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Georgia Freedman's avatar

Where is Department of Salad? Did you totally forget who got your platform all that press in the early months?

Expand full comment
T West's avatar

Ok… So you are creating another Food Network. Yay. The problem with having The Biggest Names on Substack is that it creates the same scenario as a clique…the cool kids’ lunch table. A caste system. No. Not fun.

This is what so many Substack contributors and subscribers came here to avoid in the first place. No editors, no corporate overlords, some are “nobodies” (sorry, not meant to be derogatory) who have lots to say and say it well, just good writing. It has been refreshing, personal and real. Celebrity chefs? Take it to Insta, FB & TouTube. This isn’t the platform.

I know in time, like the other Social Media platforms, Substack will surely morph into something completely different from its original conception. It will become about money, profits, and whatever the VCs want. And this is how it starts.

There are so many great contributors that have been either intentionally or unintentionally left out (hard not to do..) that this seems to go against why many people join Substack in the first place.

My concern is that this model takes off for the few in the group and it makes it harder for the rest of the food-world contributors to keep their subscribers. Not everyone can afford to subscribe to a large number of Substacks so these consolidated celebrity groups will amass tons of subscribers and many newbies who don’t yet have a great number of paid followers won’t have a chance. The current media cycle will just continue. It’s quite disheartening.

Expand full comment
100 more comments...

No posts